INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — The State Board of Education agreed Friday on a
timeline for calculating and releasing school grades, shortly before a
Marion County judge dismissed the lawsuit brought by state schools
Superintendent Glenda Ritz over control of those results.
The board also began consideration of a new school-grading formula, ahead
of a Nov. 15 deadline for approval set by lawmakers earlier this year.
Indiana's A-F school grades have been the center of a string of
controversies, from widespread accuracy concerns when they were first
issued last year, to the grade-changing scandal that cost former schools
Superintendent Tony Bennett his job as Florida's schools chief, plus the
most recent school board battle that escalated into a lawsuit.
"I am disappointed in today's ruling and concerned for all Hoosiers that
have their lives affected by unelected boards, including those that meet,
perhaps, in secret," Ritz said Friday after the board meeting.
Ritz, a Democrat, chairs the board, but the other 10 members have been
appointed by Republican Gov. Mike Pence or former Republican Gov. Mitch
Daniels. Tensions between Ritz and the other members have been growing
steadily over the past year.
New member Gordon Hendry attempted to break the tension Friday, at the
start of their first meeting since Ritz filed a lawsuit against him and
the other members. "Let the record reflect I came back," said Hendry, a
Democratic board member recently appointed by Pence. "I hope this meeting
will be a kinder, gentler one."
Ritz alleged the other members had violated Indiana's open meetings law
when they went around her last month to move calculation of the school
grades to an arm of the General Assembly. Board members have complained
that Ritz has dragged her feet on the school grades, a measure she opposed
on the campaign trail but is now tasked with enforcing as the
superintendent. But Friday's unanimous decision by the board on a timeline
for issuing the grades appeared to make many of the arguments from both
The board agreed to issue preliminary grades to schools by the end of next
week and could make the grades public by the end of the year, following an
appeals process. The grades, a new iteration of the state's school
evaluation system, are used in part to determine teacher pay and school
funding. They also have become an increasingly important tool in assessing
neighborhoods and communities.
Lawmakers had already decided earlier this year to seek an overhaul of the
grading formula when emails were published showing Bennett and his staff
had reworked the formula to raise a campaign donor's charter school from a
C to an A. A pair of legislative investigators found the changes were
applied evenly to other schools, but did not explain Bennett's decision to
craft a formula that guaranteed the school an A.
In the wake of the scandal, a bipartisan group was formed to craft a new
formula with greater transparency and a more thorough test-run of the
grades. That group delivered its recommendations to the board Friday ahead
of a statutory deadline next week.
Meanwhile, the grades for the 2012-2013 school year and the following
school year will be run through the Bennett model. The board agreed Friday
to have Ritz's Department of Education calculate the grades at the same
time the General Assembly's Legislative Services Agency runs the formula.