By VICKI URBANIK
The bill clearing the way for a 75-year lease of the Indiana Toll Road
passed the Indiana House Ways and Means Committee on a party line vote
Tuesday night, with local lawmaker State Rep. Ralph Ayres voting with fellow
Republicans in support.
Ayres said this morning that he hasn’t guaranteed that he will vote for the
bill when it comes before the full House for a final vote sometime on or
before Tuesday. But to kill the bill at this stage, he said, would have put
an end to further discussion about how the state could fund infrastructure
improvements statewide.
“Killing the bill now would not provide any solution to infrastructure
needs,” Ayres said, calling the committee vote a way to keep the issue
alive.
Gov. Mitch Daniels announced Monday that the same firm that operates the
Illinois Skyway submitted the best bid by offering $3.8 billion upfront in
exchange for the right to operate the Toll Road for 75 years. Statewide
Mobility Partners, a Spanish-Australian consortium, would be responsible for
maintaining the road and would retain all tolls collected.
The private operator would have the ability to increase tolls by at least
8.2 percent in 2010 and by at least 2 percent every year after that
beginning in 2011, under a concessionaire agreement.
The state, in turn, would use the $3.8 billion for Daniels’ highway plan
known as Major Moves, which includes a host of road and bridge projects
statewide such as the new Hoosier Heartland Highway, the I-69 highway, the
Fort to Port project that would connect Indiana to ports of Toledo, and two
Ohio River bridges. In Porter County, the projects identified in the Indiana
Department of Transportation’s 10-year plan include $45.8 million in I-94
improvements, $4.5 million on U.S. 30, the new interchange at Ind. 49 and
C.R. 400N, and additional lanes on U.S. 6 from Lake County to S.R. 149.
In addition, all of Indiana’s 92 counties, and their municipalities, would
share in $50 million in each of the next three years to be spent on road
projects. This money would be in addition to the state funds that counties
and communities already get for road projects, known as their Motor Vehicle
Highway Funds.
In Porter County, the annual breakdown of these additional MVH funds
includes the following distributions: Porter County government, $526,127;
Chesterton, $48,185; Porter, $22,843; Burns Harbor, $3,519; Dune Acres,
$978; Portage, $153,893; and Valparaiso, $126,014.
Ayres said that up until Monday, the additional MVH funds were not part of
the proposal, but that the three-year, $150 million commitment was possible
due to the higher than anticipated bid by Statewide Mobility Partners.
“Local officials have been crying for more dollars for local roads,” Ayres
said, noting that the two mayors in his district -- Valparaiso and Crown
Point -- have voiced support for Major Moves.
Although the local MVH funding is not guaranteed after three years, Ayres
said it is possible with the investment earnings of the Toll Road funds,
with estimates showing that the earnings would be greater than the revenues
now generated annually by Toll Road fares.
Overall, Gov. Mitch Daniels’ Major Moves plan commits 34 percent of the Toll
Road lease funds -- or $1.3 billion --- to the seven northern Indiana
counties along the Toll Road. When asked why northern Indiana should be
paying for Ohio River bridges or any other road projects elsewhere in the
state, Ayres said the region would not be subsidizing the others’ projects.
The reason: Twenty percent of Toll Road users are northern Indiana
motorists. The rest, he said, are out of state drivers.
“We will be getting every dollar the northern tier puts in -- plus,” he
said.
Still, Ayres said he is lobbying everywhere he can to increase northern
Indiana’s share by more than the 34 percent.
The northern Indiana funding includes the $10 million commitment by the
state over the next 10 years for the new Northwest Indiana Regional
Development Authority. The law that created the RDA last year already
guaranteed that the state would provide up to this amount for two years. But
Ayres said that money is coming from Toll Road reserves, and it will dry up
after two years. Without Major Moves, Ayres said the state contribution to
the RDA is questionable.
“The future of the RDA will be imperiled,” he said.
Ayres also argued in support of the Toll Road lease plan as an investment in
new jobs and the overall Northwest Indiana economy, citing projections that
up to 7,000 new construction jobs in Northwest Indiana will be created by
Major Moves. He added that Northwest Indiana lost 33 percent of its steel
jobs in last five years and that to guarantee well-paying jobs will require
a diversification of the economy.
Without the Toll Road lease, he said Indiana would find itself in a state of
“business as usual,” with not enough funding for road projects already on
the books and not enough state funding for local road projects.
He also said that the Toll Road revenues have not been distributed to border
counties for the last nine years, since the Toll Road has been operating at
a break-even point with all revenues going into its road maintenance. The
lease proposal will require that Statewide Mobility Partners maintain the
Toll Road at INDOT standards, which Ayres said INDOT has been unable to
achieve.
In addition, the agreement will require that the private firm install the
E-Z pass system on the Toll Road within two years. Ayres said he is working
to get a discount for in-state EZ pass users.
Weighing in on the plan Tuesday was U.S. Senator Richard Lugar, R-Ind., who
praised the plan as the “first innovative approach” for highway funding in
Indiana since the original construction of the Toll Road.
Lugar’s statement downplayed concerns about a foreign company operating the
Toll Road, noting that a British-based firm manages the Indianapolis
airport.
“Foreign investments coming to Indiana indicate our economic vitality and a
bullish view of Indiana by those making the investment and for those we are
competing to attract. Foreign-based firms are among the state’s leading
employers in steel and automobiles. They have stimulated new investment and
more better paying jobs for Hoosiers. The same will be true of this new
$3.85 billion Toll Road lease. The money will be reinvested into the state,
employing Hoosiers in construction jobs, resulting in a tremendous economic
multiplying effect,” he said.
Ayres echoed that view, noting that Indiana has a Toyota and Suburu plant
and that one of the two major steelmakers in Northwest Indiana -- Mittal
Steel -- is foreign-owned.
As for the future of the Toll Road lease bill, H.B. 1008, Ayres said the
bill will likely pass the House only with bi-partisan support. He said he
stated on the House floor that he was disappointed that he has not seen any
bipartisanship at this point. He added that four years ago, when the House
was Democrat-controlled and the governor was a Democrat, he and other
Republicans supported the state’s huge property tax overhaul.
Many of the details about the Toll Road lease and Daniels’ Major Moves plan
can be found on the governor’s website, which can be linked via the main
state website at www.IN.gov/
Posted 1/25/2006