By TOM DAVIES
Associated Press Writer
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — State regulators on Thursday issued the final
environmental permit needed for BP PLC to start work on a planned $3.8
billion expansion of its oil refinery along Lake Michigan.
The air emissions permit still needs approval from the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, but the state action allows BP to start construction work
at the Whiting refinery.
An environmental group that fought the project called the state’s review
“drive-by permitting” and said it was considering its options for appealing
the decision.
Project foes have raised concerns about increases in carbon dioxide and other
pollutants coming from the expanded refinery about 20 miles southeast of
downtown Chicago.
But Indiana Department of Environmental Management calculations are that the
refinery expansion will result in improved air quality and that the
refinery’s emissions will meet all state and federal clean air laws, said Dan
Murray, an IDEM assistant commissioner.
BP spokeswoman Valerie Corr said company officials were reviewing the state
permit but did not know of any immediate objections to conditions included by
regulators.
Some site work was to begin immediately, with completion expected in up to
four years, Corr said.
BP has said the expanded refinery would be the nation’s top processor of
heavy high-sulfur Canadian crude oil, boosting its annual production of
gasoline, diesel fuel and jet fuel by 15 percent to about 4.7 billion gallons
annually. Some 1,700 people work at the 119-year-old refinery.
Ann Alexander, senior attorney at the Natural Resources Defense Council’s
Chicago office, said pollution estimates by state regulators and BP failed to
take into account all the expected emissions from three new flares that would
be added at the refinery. Those tall chimney-like structures burn off waste
substances.
“IDEM is apparently trying to set the land speed record for issuing permits,
but they’re running roughshod over the public interest in the process,”
Alexander said.
BP officials have said that since 2001, the refinery’s overall air emissions
have declined 68 percent from an ongoing modernization project that has cut
sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, particulate matter and other emissions.
The company has projected emissions of some pollutants, such as sulfur
dioxide and particulate matter, will increase when the refinery project is
completed in 2011. But officials say levels of those pollutants will remain
below currently authorized limits.
Philip Hoffman, a spokesman for the EPA’s Chicago office, said the agency
worked closely with state regulators on the refinery permit, but would review
it in the coming weeks to ensure it meets all federal laws.
BP officials promised last summer to cut the projected discharges into Lake
Michigan of ammonia and suspended solids — tiny particles of pollution that
elude the current treatment methods. That came after Indiana regulators
approved a new permit allowing higher discharges, sparking complaints from
Chicago residents and leaders.
“IDEM is unfortunately refusing to learn from its past mistakes,” Alexander
said. “Last summer, they faced an enormous public outcry over an inadequate
permit issued with insufficient public input. They had an opportunity to do
things right this time, and they didn’t take it.”
Posted 5/2/2008