TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. (AP) — Scientists whose genetics-based research became
a lightning rod in the debate over protecting the Great Lakes from Asian
carp have made their case in a newly published article that says at least
some of the dreaded invaders have gotten beyond an electric barrier meant to
block their path to Lake Michigan.
In the paper released Wednesday, the four-member team reports Asian carp DNA
was detected in 58 water samples taken from Chicago-area rivers and canals
past the barrier over nearly a year. They caution that while the findings
suggest the presence of live bighead and silver carp, it’s unclear how many
were in the waterways because individual fish could be responsible for
multiple positive hits.
Still, the researchers argue that so-called “environmental DNA,” or “eDNA,”
has proven a more effective means of detecting Asian carp than conventional
methods such as electroshocking and netting. They predict it will become a
valuable tool in efforts to prevent exotic species invasions and preserve
species that are threatened or endangered.
“There can no longer be any question about the validity of the eDNA work and
its reliability,” David Lodge, a University of Notre Dame biologist and the
project leader, said in an interview Tuesday. “This research has with flying
colors passed the most rigorous peer review possible.”
The discovery of Asian carp DNA by Lodge and colleagues in 2009 has been at
the center of a legal dispute over whether to close shipping locks on
Chicago waterways that could serve as doorways to Lake Michigan for the
unwanted fish. They have been migrating northward in the Mississippi River
and its tributaries for decades after escaping from Southern fish farms and
Silver and bighead carp are voracious eaters of plankton — tiny plants and
animals at the base of the aquatic food chain. Biologists say if they become
established in the Great Lakes, they could starve out competitors and
threaten the $7 billion sport and commercial fishing industry.
Federal officials contend the electric barrier about 25 miles south of Lake
Michigan is adequately thwarting the carp’s advance.
Michigan and four other states have sued in federal court to close the
locks, a move resisted by barge operators and businesses that rely on cargo
shipping in the Chicago area. The U.S. Supreme Court and U.S. District Judge
Robert Dow last year denied requests to close the locks immediately, but the
lawsuit is going forward.
Lodge testified about the eDNA research during a hearing before Dow, drawing
skeptical questioning from attorneys for Chicago shipping interests. Critics
have attacked the work by Lodge and his colleagues with Notre Dame and The
Nature Conservancy, noting it hadn’t been published in a peer-reviewed
journal — a criticism Dow echoed in his Dec. 2 ruling.
The scientists said the results were made public quickly because of the
urgent threat posed by Asian carp, and they said a scientific panel with the
Environmental Protection Agency had endorsed their methodology. But on
Wednesday, a 15-page paper describing their techniques and findings was
published in the online edition of Conservation Letters, a journal produced
by the Society for Conservation Biology.
“I hope this will lead to a shift in the debate from questioning the science
to looking for some real solutions,” Nature Conservancy biologist Lindsay
The paper says the team analyzed more than 1,000 water samples taken from
the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal and neighboring waterways. Asian carp
DNA was found in 128 of those, including 58 beyond the electric barrier.
Just one actual Asian carp has been found past the barrier. Still, Notre
Dame scientist Andrew Mahon said the eDNA showed that “the invasion front
for bighead and silver carp is much closer to the Great Lakes than people
The group is seeking funding to study how many carp are beyond the barrier,
said biologist Christopher Jerde, also of Notre Dame.
David Rieser, an attorney representing industry groups opposed to shutting
the locks, said they were eager to study the team’s data but remained
unconvinced it would make a solid case for lock closure.
“Just because the data is published in a peer-reviewed journal doesn’t make
it gospel,” Rieser said. “And it’s far from clear that it will be of any use
in the discussions about the best control measures for the Chicago waterway
Invasive species expert James Carlton of Williams College, who wasn’t
involved with the study but has read the paper, described the methodology as
“solid” and said eDNA could help government agencies detect and respond to
invasions more quickly instead of just fixing damage to the environment and
the economy when it’s too late.
“It will save a huge amount of taxpayer dollars in the long run,” Carlton