By KEVIN NEVERS
As the officials and employees of the Town of Burns Harbor waited today for
news of an emergency loan which the General Assembly may or may not have
enacted to bail out Porter County taxing units affected by the bankruptcy of
Bethlehem Steel Corporation, one Chesterton Town Council member is floating
an idea which he believes could forestall Burns Harbor’s own possible
liquidation and dis-incorporation, as it faces the next 18 months without a
property tax payment from the steel giant.
Merger.
Bob Crone, R-3rd, told the Chesterton Tribune Monday that a merger of the
towns of Chesterton and Burns Harbor would enable the latter to survive as a
municipality with the same level of services which its residents now enjoy.
“We have the same schools,” he said. “We have the same library. We speak the
same language. I think it would be a positive for both towns.”
Crone had not formally broached the idea to Burns Harbor officials when he
spoke to the Tribune on Monday, but today Burns Harbor Clerk-Treasurer
Esther Nickell made it clear that her Town Council was not considering
merger as an option. “That’s actually (Crone’s) idea,” she said. “As far as
I know none of our council is inclined for that. They’re not inclined for
that.”
And Nickell added that she has “absolutely not” heard talk of it in other
quarters of her town.
Although Crone also serves currently as the President of the Duneland
Chamber of Commerce, he appeared to be speaking only in his capacity as a
member of the Chesterton Town Council. Laurie Franke-Polz, executive
director of the Chamber, was not available this morning to comment on the
Chamber’s official position on a possible merger.
Crone’s colleague on the council, however, Sharon Darnell, D-4th, urged
caution in the matter. “I realize that it looks good on paper,” she said.
“And we could justify it from our point of view. But I just can’t see
jumping into this. There are too many options now. Maybe it should have
happened years ago. But right now people are just too darned scared to make
rational decisions.”
Under Indiana Code 36-4-2-(1-17) a merger is possible—the two towns abut at
C.R. 1100N between Ind. 149 and C.R. 200W—and could be implemented in one of
two ways: if the council of each town agrees by resolution to hold an
election to consider a merger, or if at least 10 percent of the qualified
voters of each town sign a petition requesting such an election.
Feasibility is different from legality, however, and in Crone’s view
Chesterton’s existing departments could provide the extra level of services
without particular economic hardship. “It seems like a minimum of new
employees would be needed by Chesterton because there’s so much duplication
of services,” he said. Crone suggested, for instance, that the new corporate
entity—voters would have to approve its name in the same election in which
they approved the merger itself—would probably require one additional
employee for the Street Department, one for the Parks and Recreation
Department, and maybe one or two for the Police Department.
“When you spread out services over more people,” Crone said, “it comes out
to less cost per person.” In any event, he projected, the property tax
revenues of a new corporate entity would likely support a couple of extra
employees.
Chesterton Clerk-Treasurer Gayle Polakowski was not available today for
comment, but two department heads were and they indicated that their
resources are already strained. Street Commissioner John Schnadenberg noted
that, with new subdivisions being added to Chesterton all the time,
“whatever equipment (Burns Harbor has) would have to carry over because
we’re at our limits now.” Bottom line: his Street Department would indeed
need at least one more employee. “To take on square miles,” he said, “we
would need to take on one more individual, given that we’re at our limits
now.”
Police Chief George Nelson, on the other hand, observed that in a new
corporate entity his officers would be tasked with the patrol not only of
Burns Harbor’s municipal roadways but with stretches of Ind. 149, U.S.
Highway 20, U.S. Highway 12, two mobile home parks, the Williams Travel
Center, and various industrial facilities. He projected a need for a minimum
of six new officers: or two per crew. “We could use one or two extra
officers right now with what we have,” Nelson said. “Sometimes we need to
pull a detective to cover a shift.”
One question to which Crone did not know the answer is what exactly would
happen to the agreement reached by Burns Harbor and Bethlehem under which
the former is to purchase the latter’s wastewater treatment plant. A new
corporate entity would have no need of that plant, said Chesterton Utility
Service Board President Larry Brandt, who noted that “from a capacity point
of view, there is no question that (Chesterton’s expanded plant) could
process whatever comes out of Burns Harbor.”
Is it possible that Burns Harbor residents might take a dim view of a
merger, might be inclined to see it as Chesterton’s taking advantage of a
fire sale?
“I hope that they wouldn’t see it that way,” said Crone. “I hope that they
would look at it as a way of saving themselves. Really we’re no different
from one another. It just seems like it would be a natural thing to do.”